"Practice Makes Perfect"
is Terrible Advice
For Travel Writing
(and Everything Else)

By Roy Stevenson

“Practice makes perfect”.  This widely accepted idiom is accepted as the ultimate truth. It’s touted as the key to success in everything from sports performance to travel journalism.

The problem is, it’s terrible advice!

The premise is the more we do something, the better we get at doing it.  On the surface, this seems to make sense.

However, the huge loophole in this argument is, if you do something the wrong way from the start, it doesn’t matter how many times you practice.  Practice makes perfect means you'll simply become really good at doing something the wrong way.  And you’ll continue to do it the wrong way.  This is a hazard for travel writing and any other thing we do.

So, what if you are doing your travel writing the wrong way?

practice makes perfect means you have to do it right to begin with

For travel writers, if your basic spelling, grammar and punctuation are poor, doing lots and lots of writing will not improve these fundamental skills.  You need feedback to help you improve these basic writing skills. 

The same principle applies to your overall writing style and technique, also known as your ‘voice’.

Without personal feedback, you’re doomed to keep writing the same old way and you’ll keep making the same old mistakes. Your unpolished writing will scream “amateur” to magazine editors when they read your query letters and articles.

Now let me dispel another myth:

It’s not the magazine editor’s job to tidy up your travel writing!

The belief that editors are happy to clean up your spelling, punctuation, and grammar, and rewrite your poorly written paragraphs, will lead to great disappointment in your freelance writing career. As harsh as this may sound, if your creative writing is not up to snuff, you have no business pitching your travel stories to magazine editors.

Without instructive feedback, your voice won’t develop and your articles will sound superficial. 

Unless you’re a natural, gifted writer, your stories will not flow smoothly especially when you’re just getting started.  You won’t know how to paint a clear picture of your destination in the reader’s imagination. Your writing won’t make the reader want to go there.

It’s easy for readers to recognize sub-standard travel writing.  We see it in travel writing everywhere on the Internet. 

Don’t let poor examples mislead you into thinking that writing proficiency doesn’t matter.  It matters a great deal!

Here are eight of the most common travel writing errors I see.  Which ones can you find in your own articles?

writing skills and style error infographic

Good travel writing reads smoothly and easily.  It keeps you reading right up to the final sentence because you want to see how it ends. In short, good travel writing is polished, entertaining, easy to read and clearly presented.

Perfect Practice Makes Perfect Travel Writing

Only when you learn how to do something correctly, and then practice it multiple times, will your travel writing approach perfection.  Perfect practice makes perfect travel writing.

If you’re a new travel writer, or a travel writer wanting to move to the next level, you need direct feedback.  Bear in mind that feedback is a repetitive process.  When I coach my clients, for example, I use a “feedback loop”.  I give my clients feedback on their query letter or manuscript and then they rewrite them.  If necessary, I'll recommend further changes until they're ready to submit to editors.

Of course, you can also choose to ignore the feedback and continue to write poorly.  This is a situation where practice makes perfect results in failures.  You won’t have much success selling your articles to editors if you don't learn to write a good query.

If you want to improve your creative travel writing skills, here are five ways to do that – and I suggest you use them all!

Perfect Practice Make Perfect Writing with Self Study: Read Creative Writing Books

Buying books about the art and craft of creative writing (and then reading them!) will certainly help novice travel writers and bloggers improve their work.

When you use this Do-It-Yourself approach, you must be motivated and disciplined enough to follow through.  Spend time every day reading the books you purchased.  Even if you only spend a half hour each day reading, you will learn how to improve. 

Of course, you also need to apply what you learned when you sit down to write!

Perfect Practice Makes Perfect Writing by Reading Top Shelf Travel Articles

Another way to improve your writing is by reading good travel writing.  You can really amp up your craft by reading travel articles in respected, top shelf travel magazines.

For this to be effective, read the articles actively and critically.  Study the stories for style, voice, and flow. 

Actively note specific examples and techniques the writer used to make her story effective.  Then try out some of these techniques when you sit down to write.

Over the years I’ve read thousands of travel blogs and noticed one commonality between the best blogs — they’re all well written.  The best travel bloggers are no different than print travel writers.  They use the same creative writing techniques found in print publications.

Readers prefer well-written articles, whether they’re reading online or in print.    

I get that travel blogs are often shorter than what you might find in print.  But they read so much better when they’re comprehensible. A short, effective five-hundred-word blog will still captivate your readers if it’s well written.

Perfect Practice Makes Perfect Writing by Comparing Your Original Manuscript With the Published Article

Another powerful way I get feedback is by reviewing my articles after they’ve been published in print magazines. I’ll place my original manuscript on the left side of my computer screen and a PDF of my published article on the right side of the screen. I compare the two articles simultaneously, sentence-by-sentence, to see how the editor has changed my story.

I’ve gained tremendous feedback using this simple side-by-side comparison technique. This is essentially a free coaching session with your editor. I’ve seen how editors make my story ‘tight’ by eliminating unnecessary words, or even whole sentences. Sometimes editors will exchange one word for another simpler or more appropriate word.

One of the major ways I improved my travel writing when I was new at the game was through these side-by-side comparisons.  Seeing how editors swapped some of my paragraphs around to make the story flow better and to give it a ‘punchier’ start was enlightening.

During my first few years in the freelance writing game, I had a tendency to lead off my story (called a ‘lede’) with a bland statement, followed by a much juicier and more descriptive paragraph. I noticed that frequently, editors would swap my first two paragraphs around so that my highly descriptive second paragraph was promoted to the lede, and my original paragraph was inserted further down the article.

Even today, I still occasionally lead off with a mundane paragraph, but now that I’m aware of this tendency, I often promote a more exciting paragraph from further down my article up to the lede. I usually do this when I’ve finished my story and am polishing it.

Perfect Practice Makes Perfect Writing by Taking a Class in Creative Writing

If your writing skills are inadequate, but you still want to break into travel writing, find a creative writing class at a local university or community college.  You can find classes for everything from basic spelling, grammar, and punctuation, to writing creatively.

If you don’t have a local college or university program, there are some good online programs.  Nick O’Connell offers such programs online and gives feedback to writers as part of his classes.  

But, no matter what course you take, make sure personal feedback is part of the curriculum.

Perfect Practice Makes Perfect Writing by Hiring a writing coach and getting feedback

The self-improvement techniques I’ve outlined above will help you improve your writing. But hiring a writing coach and mentor stands out head-and-shoulders above all other methods.

In this marvelous digital era of email and Skype, a writing coach will give you precisely the advice you need to improve.

I’m not referring to lame packaged programs where you pay exorbitant sums of money for a series of canned online presentations, with a few sketchy handouts thrown in to sweeten the pot.  Packaged programs do not provide you with what you need most: personalized feedback on your writing.

When I suggest hiring a writing coach, I’m referring to one-on-one coaching and mentoring.  A coach provides individualized mentoring to move you forward rapidly to the next level.

A good writing coach will review your query letters and story manuscripts before you submit them to editors.  A writing mentor will teach you techniques on writing style and help you develop your voice.

Practice makes perfect for travel writers requires a feedback loop.  Hire a writing coach to improve your writing.  Learn from the feedback.  Try out the new techniques your coach recommends.  Then look at the results, and repeat until you are proficient.  

You’ll know when this happens because your perfect practice makes perfect travel writing - and will  produce better results.

Related articles that will interest you:

Your Travel Writing Craft Resource Page

Your Travel Writing Craft: 10 Ways to Write Like a Seasoned Professional

Seven Tips to Improve Your Writing Style

Roy Stevenson sitting in front of his computer.

Roy Stevenson is a professional travel writer and the author of www.PitchTravelWrite.com.  Over the past ten years, he’s had more than 1000 articles published in 200 magazines, trade and specialty journals, in-flights, on-boards, blogs and websites and has traveled on assignment around the U.S. and to dozens of international destinations.